A nonprofit division of Sevadar Foundation Inc.

For clinicians  ·  For facilities  ·  For families  ·  For staff

The evidence base

The evidence base

Everything the framework asserts should be traceable to something published, and where it is not, that should be said out loud. These pages set out the tools, the trials and the syntheses that the field rests on — including the places where the evidence is weaker than the confidence it is quoted with.

The pages

The Beers Criteria

What the AGS list is, what it is not, and the misreading that turns a prompt into a prohibition.

STOPP/START

Two lists in one tool — what to stop, and the omissions that matter just as much.

Deprescribing and falls

The claim that gets made most often, and what the trials actually found.

Polypharmacy in long-term care

How much medication is really on the list, in which populations, by which definition.

What deprescribing trials measure

Why a field can be well studied and still not answer the question you are asking.

Antipsychotics and mortality in dementia

The boxed warning, the meta-analyses behind it, and the size of the risk.

Time to benefit

A preventive drug that takes five years to help, in someone with a two-year outlook.

How sources are handled here

  • Every figure carries a source, or it is not published. A page with fewer numbers is better than a page with one wrong one.
  • Every figure names its population and its criterion in the same sentence. “Polypharmacy affects half of older adults” is not a fact until you know which older adults and what counts as polypharmacy.
  • Systematic reviews and meta-analyses outrank single trials, randomized evidence outranks observational, and where a claim rests on observation rather than randomization, the page says so.
  • A guideline is cited as a guideline, not as evidence of effect.
  • Where the evidence is thin, the page gets longer, not more skeptical. Naming the exclusion criteria of a trial is a verifiable fact about that trial, and it is usually the most useful thing a complex patient can learn about it.

What the evidence does and does not show

Sedating medications impair gait, balance and reaction time, and their labels say so. That part is not in doubt. What has not been shown is that a deprescribing program reduces fall rates — the trials that tested it were small, short, and mostly measured a medication count rather than a fracture. Those are two different questions, and absence of evidence from underpowered trials is not evidence that the drugs do not cause falls. What the evidence actually shows about deprescribing and falls.

Written and medically reviewed by Dr. Gurpreet Singh Padda, MD, MBA, MHP, founder and medical director of DWARAA. Last reviewed . This page is educational. DWARAA does not prescribe, deprescribe, diagnose or treat.